Gracie Abrams and Marcus Mumford’s “What If It’s Right” captures two people caught between fear and hope, questioning whether a complicated relationship is worth fighting for. Through vulnerable reflections, emotional scars, and lingering devotion, they wonder if walking away is a mistake and whether uncertain love could ultimately be the right choice.
What If It’s Right Lyrics
[Verse 1: Gracie Abrams]
High, cleaner air, in your shirt
I’m a dark figure who left kinder words by the door
By the cold river, it bends, but I won’t
Like a stone and I’ll sink when I’m alone
[Verse 2: Gracie Abrams & Marcus Mumford]
Hit where it hurts, where you know
You can reach me like a dog
On your floor, we both swore to go easy, but we won’t
It’s a sick undertone, I’m a knife cut to the bone
[Chorus: Gracie Abrams & Marcus Mumford]
This could be the wrong thing
But what if it’s right?
So why are we leaving?
But is it the wrong thing?
But what if it’s right?
What if it’s right?
[Verse 3: Gracie Abrams & Marcus Mumford, Gracie Abrams]
Look in my eyes when I speak
When I scream, how do you not
Even hеar anything?
Built a fort, swallowed the key
And I’vе bled through my knees
Hard to beg or to believe (Hmm)
In time, funny time, funny boy, funny
I felt like a joke half my life through the noise
Silent cries, evidence shows
Cunning ploy
Humming, I think I want more
[Chorus: Gracie Abrams & Marcus Mumford]
This could be the wrong thing
But what if it’s right?
What are we even doing?
But is it the wrong thing?
But what if it’s right?
What if it’s right?
[Instrumental Break]
[Verse 4: Gracie Abrams]
Soft on my skin, where you land at the end, end of our days
I might break you, but you broke me back all the same
Slow decay, slow decay
Ain’t it sad sharing this stage?
[Verse 5: Gracie Abrams & Marcus Mumford]
Soft on your skin, where I land at the end, end of our days
I know you better than anything, you know me the same
Heaven’s gate, heaven’s gate
Will you please make it okay?
[Chorus: Gracie Abrams & Marcus Mumford, Marcus Mumford]
This could be the wrong thing
But what if it’s right?
Then why are we leaving?
But is it the wrong thing?
But what if it’s right?
What if it’s right?
This could be the wrong thing
What if it’s right?
Don’t wanna be leaving
But is it the wrong thing?
But what if it’s right? (Right)
What if it’s right?
[Outro: Gracie Abrams]
What if it’s right?
Video of What If It’s Right Lyrics By Gracie Abrams & Marcus Mumford
Song Credits
- Song Name :– What If It’s Right
- Singer Name :–Gracie Abrams & Marcus Mumford
- Producer:- Aaron Dessner
- Album:– Daughter from Hell
- Release Date :– July 17, 2026
Song Bio of What If It’s Right
Gracie Abrams and Marcus Mumford trade quiet confessions like two people who already know the answer but can’t say it out loud. “What If It’s Right” sits in that ache between letting go and holding on, where love feels like a wound that won’t quite close. Their voices weave together, tender and worn, asking the same question from opposite sides of the same heartbreak.
Produced by Aaron Dessner for the album “Daughter from Hell,” the track trades big drama for something smaller and truer, two people staring at the wreckage and wondering if it was ever really wreckage at all.
